|此维基百科页目前正依照en:Wikipedia:One sentence does not an article make上的内容进行翻译。 (2019年12月31日)|
As an example of a sentence, take "Harold Blowman (1957–1994) was an American actor best known for his performance as 'Billy' in the movie Don't Shoot the Monkey." This single sentence actually states more about the subject of the article than many stub articles of thrice the length which are "padded" with unsourced POV adjectives ("renown","gifted","highly-acclaimed", etc.) and dubious attempts at "notability through association" ("Blowman was part of the social circle that included [famous person A], [famous person B] and [celebrity C]").
But what does this sentence really say about Harold Blowman? Not much. It doesn't state who he was or establish whether he merits an article under Wikipedia's notability guidelines. Was his portrayal of 'Billy' commented on by film critics? Did he do other acting on stage or on the screen that garnered the attention of reviewers? Did his acting influence other actors? Was he associated with a particular notable director? Why did the editor spend a significant amount of his (or her) time to write this one sentence definition, and was that time well spent?
The last question can be answered definitively: NO. If an editor cannot find enough information on a subject to be able to write at least four non-repetitive sentences about him/her/it, then the article should not be started until there is sufficient information to "do it justice." If there is not enough information for at least four sentences of writing, it is most likely that the subject of the proposed article doesn't merit one in the first place under the notability guidelines.
This is an application of the Reasonability Rule: is it reasonable to expect that a single sentence is worth the time and effort to write and read with an expectation of being "illuminated" with encyclopedic information? Since it is not, one sentence articles (and, by a similar argument, two sentence articles) violate the Reasonability Rule in the context of an encyclopedia.
- Wikipedia:Reasonability Rule
- Wikipedia:Don't be inconsiderate
- Wikipedia:Put a little effort into it
- Observations on Wikipedia behavior
- That Blowman hung out with these people does not, in itself, give him notability. Of course, if [famous person B]'s biography states that "Blowman was a crucial artistic influence on [famous person B]'s acting style", then it may help the case of establishing his notability.